{
  "uri": "alkn://truthloops/securities/product-form-premium-10-25pct-disambiguation",
  "contents": [
    {
      "uri": "alkn://truthloops/securities/product-form-premium-10-25pct-disambiguation",
      "mimeType": "application/json",
      "text": "{\n  \"source_role\": \"doctrine\",\n  \"observation_type\": \"doctrine\",\n  \"evidence_payload_retrievable\": false,\n  \"scope_temporal\": \"permanent_doctrine\",\n  \"loop_id\": \"product-form-premium-10-25pct-disambiguation\",\n  \"branch\": \"physical-asset\",\n  \"polarity\": \"negative_disambiguation\",\n  \"bounded_proposition\": \"A cited 10–25% conversion premium may describe a lower-order comparison involving ordinary drawn wire or feedstock conversion. It must NOT be used to price ultrafine 0.025 mm NP1 inventory unless the source matches grade, diameter, tolerance, condition, quantity, certification and transaction basis.\",\n  \"required_evidence\": [\n    \"Exact source and baseline of the cited 10–25% figure (cathode → ordinary wire · standard diameter → fine wire · distributor margin · manufacturing conversion · historical industrial transaction · purity premium · traceability premium · certified-inventory premium — which one?)\",\n    \"Specification match between the source premium and the target inventory (grade, diameter, tolerance, condition, quantity, certification, transaction basis)\",\n    \"Product-class alignment (raw nickel, ordinary drawn wire, ultrafine 0.025 mm NP1 wire, qualified application-specific component, converted device — which class does the premium describe?)\"\n  ],\n  \"required_wording\": {\n    \"use\": [\n      \"Ordinary drawn nickel wire may trade at a comparatively modest premium to nickel feedstock. That observation does not establish the value of ultrafine 0.025 mm NP1 wire, whose economics may include many additional drawing stages, process losses, handling difficulty, dimensional control, surface requirements, testing, traceability, packaging and qualification.\",\n      \"The amount of the specialty premium must nevertheless be supported by specification-matched market evidence.\",\n      \"10–25% and 65,000× may describe different points in the product-value chain. They are not inherently contradictory.\",\n      \"If the 10–25% premium is an ordinary drawn-wire premium over cathode, it does not directly price 0.025 mm NP1 wire. It can be retained as a lower product-category comparator, not as a contradiction of the specialty appraisal.\"\n    ],\n    \"do_not_use\": [\n      \"\\\"10–25% versus 65,000× is an inconsistency\\\" — this framing invalidly compares different product classes and value bases\",\n      \"\\\"Ordinary wire carries only a 10–25% premium, so ultrafine NP1 wire should carry only that premium\\\" — this silently reclassifies the asset\",\n      \"\\\"10–25%\\\" placed next to \\\"65,000×\\\" without specifying the exact baseline\"\n    ]\n  },\n  \"correct_relationship\": \"The product-class chain is: raw nickel ≠ ordinary converted nickel wire ≠ ultrafine 0.025 mm NP1 wire ≠ qualified application-specific component ≠ converted mesh/electrode/device. A percentage applicable to one transition cannot be applied automatically to another. Before propagating the 10–25% figure, the federation must identify which baseline it describes (cathode-to-ordinary-wire, standard-to-fine diameter, distributor margin, manufacturing conversion, historical industrial transaction, purity, traceability, or certified-inventory premium).\",\n  \"closure_condition\": \"PERMANENT disambiguation loop. Active whenever the 10–25% conversion premium (or any percentage premium) is cited in proximity to the ALKN inventory or the specialty-wire appraisal.\",\n  \"do_not_publish\": [\n    \"The 10–25% premium propagated without its exact baseline\",\n    \"The 10–25% premium treated as directly applicable to ultrafine 0.025 mm NP1 wire\",\n    \"The 10–25% premium framed as contradicting the specialty appraisal\",\n    \"\\\"Only approximately 30.7 kg\\\" — the word \\\"only\\\" is advocacy, not analysis; the correct wording describes the product as approximately 29.5 kg fabricated into approximately seven million metres of ultrafine wire\"\n  ],\n  \"linked_loops\": [\n    \"edison-65000x-positive-product-form-indicator\",\n    \"edison-65000x-negative-not-automatic-validity\",\n    \"realizable-value\",\n    \"specification-conformance\"\n  ],\n  \"status\": \"OPEN\",\n  \"effective_date\": \"2026-09-17\"\n}"
    }
  ]
}