{
  "uri": "alkn://truthloops/np1/negative-bulk-quote-not-comparable",
  "contents": [
    {
      "uri": "alkn://truthloops/np1/negative-bulk-quote-not-comparable",
      "mimeType": "application/json",
      "text": "{\n  \"source_role\": \"doctrine\",\n  \"observation_type\": \"doctrine\",\n  \"evidence_payload_retrievable\": false,\n  \"scope_temporal\": \"permanent_doctrine\",\n  \"loop_id\": \"negative-bulk-quote-not-comparable\",\n  \"polarity\": \"negative_disambiguation\",\n  \"proposition\": \"DISAMBIGUATION: A bulk quotation for nickel wire does NOT prove the realizable value of the stored NP1 inventory. A price comparison is valid only after matching grade, chemistry, diameter, tolerance, temper, mechanical properties, surface, continuity, lot consistency, test method, certification, traceability, origin, packaging, spool condition, minimum order, available quantity, delivery terms, payment terms, qualification status, buyer acceptance and transaction date.\",\n  \"bounded_meaning\": \"A low advertised quotation is counterevidence requiring investigation, but it is NOT automatically a completed arm's-length transaction or an exact comparable. The valuation Truthloop weighs quotations, transactions and completed sales as separate levels of market evidence.\",\n  \"required_evidence\": [\n    \"Full 15-factor specification match against the compared quotation\",\n    \"Verification that the quotation is fillable (available quantity, delivery terms)\",\n    \"Verification that the quotation would clear buyer-acceptance criteria\",\n    \"Distinction between advertised quote, executable bid and completed transaction\"\n  ],\n  \"positive_edges\": [\n    {\n      \"type\": \"disambiguation\",\n      \"source\": \"IVS International Valuation Standards on specialty-material comparables\",\n      \"scope\": \"Specification-matched comparables are the doctrine for specialty materials; anonymous bulk quotes are not direct comparables\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"type\": \"disambiguation\",\n      \"source\": \"Alessandro catalogue-to-volume challenge\",\n      \"scope\": \"The catalogue-to-volume challenge is preserved as counterevidence to be investigated, not overridden and not accepted as an established replacement value\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"negative_edges\": [\n    {\n      \"type\": \"counterevidence\",\n      \"source\": \"Bulk-quote-as-realizable-value assumption\",\n      \"scope\": \"\\\"A bulk quotation proves the realizable value of the stored NP1 inventory\\\" is not supported by valuation doctrine\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"unresolved_edges\": [\n    {\n      \"type\": \"unresolved\",\n      \"source\": \"Specification-matched executable bids\",\n      \"scope\": \"Not ingested\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"type\": \"unresolved\",\n      \"source\": \"Specification-matched completed sales\",\n      \"scope\": \"Not ingested\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"closure_condition\": \"Permanent disambiguation loop. Active whenever a bulk quotation is asserted as a realizable-value comparable.\",\n  \"do_not_publish\": [\n    \"Bulk-quote-based realizable-value replacements\",\n    \"Treatment of advertised quotations as completed arm's-length transactions\",\n    \"Erasure of the Alessandro challenge; and equally, treatment of the challenge as an established replacement value\"\n  ],\n  \"linked_loops\": [\n    \"np1-strategic-supply-premium\",\n    \"disambiguation-grade-name-not-lot-proof\",\n    \"negative-nominal-diameter-not-conformance\",\n    \"negative-purity-pct-alone-not-equivalence\",\n    \"negative-origin-not-non-equivalence\"\n  ],\n  \"linked_resources\": [\n    \"alkn://claims/valuation\",\n    \"alkn://counterevidence/valuation\",\n    \"alkn://truthloops/valuation\"\n  ],\n  \"status\": \"OPEN\",\n  \"effective_date\": \"2026-09-17\"\n}"
    }
  ]
}