{
  "uri": "alkn://truthloops/np1/disambiguation-commissioned-interview-not-independent-market-evidence",
  "contents": [
    {
      "uri": "alkn://truthloops/np1/disambiguation-commissioned-interview-not-independent-market-evidence",
      "mimeType": "application/json",
      "text": "{\n  \"source_role\": \"doctrine\",\n  \"observation_type\": \"doctrine\",\n  \"evidence_payload_retrievable\": false,\n  \"scope_temporal\": \"permanent_doctrine\",\n  \"loop_id\": \"disambiguation-commissioned-interview-not-independent-market-evidence\",\n  \"polarity\": \"negative_disambiguation\",\n  \"proposition\": \"An interview of a party connected to the ALKN/Alkemya Metacore project reported by a trade publication is REPORTED SPEECH of a related party. It is NOT independent market-evidence of specialty-nickel realizable value, NOT independent corroboration of ALKN, and NOT a financial promotion.\",\n  \"bounded_meaning\": \"The interview is evidence that the interview was published and that the interviewee expressed an opinion. It is not evidence that the opinion is correct, that the predicted market behaviour will occur, or that any third-party market participant endorses the interviewee's view. The same discipline applies to all trade-press coverage of related parties, not only to this one interview.\",\n  \"required_evidence\": [\n    \"Named interviewee's stated relationship to the project (director/employee/counterparty)\",\n    \"Publication metadata (publisher, author, date)\",\n    \"Scope note distinguishing reported speech from independent market-evidence\",\n    \"Explicit disclaimer that no third-party endorsement is implied\"\n  ],\n  \"positive_edges\": [\n    {\n      \"type\": \"disambiguation\",\n      \"source\": \"Related-party evidence discipline\",\n      \"scope\": \"Reported speech of a related party is a documentable statement but not independent evidence of the matter asserted\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"type\": \"disambiguation\",\n      \"source\": \"Trade-press editorial discipline\",\n      \"scope\": \"A reputable trade publication reporting an interview attests that the interview occurred and was reported in good faith; it does not attest the truth of the interviewee's predictions or opinions\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"negative_edges\": [\n    {\n      \"type\": \"counterevidence\",\n      \"source\": \"Independent-corroboration conflation\",\n      \"scope\": \"\\\"S&P Global/Platts validates ALKN\\\" or \\\"trade press confirms specialty-nickel premium\\\" misrepresents reported speech of a related party as independent corroboration\"\n    },\n    {\n      \"type\": \"counterevidence\",\n      \"source\": \"Financial-promotion risk\",\n      \"scope\": \"An ALKN-side page that quotes or amplifies a related-party interview without the related-party and no-endorsement disclaimers would read as a financial promotion of a regulated token — forbidden by the ALKN Evidence Programme\"\n    }\n  ],\n  \"unresolved_edges\": [],\n  \"closure_condition\": \"This is a PERMANENT doctrine loop. It remains active whenever any trade-press interview or coverage of a related party (director, employee, sponsor, counterparty, affiliate) is cited in connection with ALKN or the Alkemya Metacore inventory.\",\n  \"do_not_publish\": [\n    \"Any suggestion that the S&P/Platts interview validates, endorses, or confirms ALKN or the Alkemya Metacore inventory\",\n    \"Any quotation from licensed Platts content (S&P licence prohibits reproduction, extraction, derivative works without written consent)\",\n    \"Any price forecast derived from the interview\",\n    \"Any ALKN-surface wording that reads as a financial promotion based on the interview\"\n  ],\n  \"linked_loops\": [\n    \"disambiguation-grade-name-not-lot-proof\",\n    \"disambiguation-mass-basis-label-vs-theoretical\"\n  ],\n  \"linked_resources\": [\n    \"alkn://evidence/doc-platts-sood-interview-2026-11-02\",\n    \"alkn://doctrine/related-party-evidence\"\n  ],\n  \"status\": \"OPEN\",\n  \"effective_date\": \"2026-11-06\"\n}"
    }
  ]
}